A
boy band (or
boyband) is loosely defined as a
popular music act consisting of only
male singers. The members are expected to
dance as well as
sing, usually giving highly
choreographed performances. More often than not, boy band members do not play
musical instruments, either in recording sessions or on stage, and only sing and dance, making the term somewhat of a
misnomer. However, exceptions do exist. In many cases boy bands are brought together by a producer through an
audition process, although many of them form on their own.
History
Early history
The earliest form of boy band music took place in the late 19th century with the use of a capella
Barbershop quartets. They were usually a group of males and sing in four part harmonies. The popularity of Barbershop quartets had been prominent into the earlier part of the 20th century. A revival of the male vocal group took place in the late 1940s and 1950s with the use of
doo-wop music. Doo wop was a predecessor to the previous boy bands and they sung about topics such as love and other themes used in pop music. The earliest traces of boy bands were in the mid 1950s and the term boy band was not used. The Ink Spots was one of the first boy bands. The term boy band was not established until the late 1980s. Before that times they were called male vocal groups or hep harmony singing groups.
[1]
1960s
The earliest predecessors of the boy band genre were groups such as
The Osmonds,
The Jackson 5, and
The Monkees, which helped form the template for boy bands. While
The Monkees were originally a manufactured act turned real band that featured members with distinct (albeit fictional) personality types,
The Jackson 5 were a family group that established many musical conventions that boy bands follow. For instance, their music featured
close harmonies from
soul music and catchy pop hooks influenced as much as they were
Motown acts like
The Supremes. All members of the band sang, which is a common convention of boy band, as opposed to having a front man and the rest on instruments. This is effectively so that no one person dominated the stage. Even so, the members conveniently fitted into the convention of having stereotypical personality types (
Michael Jackson being the "
cute one", to give an obvious example).
Although not a manufactured band,
The Beatles set a precedent for boy bands to follow both in terms of marketing to young girls and certain aesthetic and musical conventions. The merchandising, whether it was films like
A Hard Day's Night or novelty goods were possibly the first aimed at a certain demographic on a large scale for a group. This made them a proto-type for boy bands, such as
The Jackson 5 and
The Monkees. Musical conventions that boy bands adopted from The Beatles were less their technical proficiency as musicians and more the catchy pop hooks, melodies and harmonies combined with their marketability. Their marketability was based the idea that there was something for everyone, whether it is the music or the personality of
John Lennon or
Paul McCartney or their
sex appeal.
The Beatles were more directly an influence on boy bands that use rock band instrumentation. The precedent for this was when TV Producers
Bert Schneider and
Bob Rafelson got four members to perform catchy pop tunes while also acting in a television series. The
Monkees are often considered as the original pioneers among boy bands. Formed in 1965 under the supervision of
Don Kirshner, the group became dissatisfied with Kirshner's control and became independent two years later, and worked on their own up to 1970.
1970s and 1980s
Although the term "boy band" is mostly associated with groups from the 1990s onwards, other antecedents (apart from those already mentioned) exist throughout the history of pop music. The genre has been copied into languages and cultures other than the Anglo-American. There is a popular Russian boy band
Ivanushki International. The Puerto Rican boy band
Menudo, appealing to young
Latina audiences, was founded in 1977. Menudo had a convention unique among boy bands: when a member turned 16, became too tall, or their voice changed, they were ejected and replaced. Members of Menudo were generally aged 12–14.
The
Bay City Rollers were a
Scottish pop band who were most popular in the mid 1970s. The
British Hit Singles & Albums noted that they were "
tartan teen sensations from
Edinburgh", and were "the first of many acts heralded as the 'Biggest Group since The Beatles' and one of the most screamed-at teeny-bopper acts of the 1970s".
[2] For a relatively brief but fervent period (nicknamed "Rollermania"), they were worldwide
teen idols. The group were one of the first bands like
The Monkees before them to take the formula shown by
The Beatles and apply it to a teen market. The group achieved the same amount of success but for a limited period of time. At the peak of their popularity in the UK, comparisons were being made to
The Beatles. Also by this time, Bay City Roller
fans had a completely distinctive style of dress, the main elements of which were ankle-length
tartan trousers and tartan
scarves, the group using the benefit of merchandise and promotion.
[3]
In the U.S., the
Cleveland-based
power pop group
Raspberries was generally interpreted as a "teen act", although all the band members played their own music.
Vocalist Eric Carmen later commented, "You’d have a thousand screaming girls in the front of the stage and then ten very serious rock critics in the back of the room going, ‘Uh-huh, I think we understand this.’ And unfortunately the great mass of pot-smoking 18 year-olds that bought albums and made you a substantial commodity in the great marketing world of records never took to us. It was not hip for people to like us, because their little sister liked us.
[4]
Bros (abbreviation of the word "brothers") were a British boy band active in the late 1980s and early 1990s, consisting of twin brothers
Matt Goss and
Luke Goss along with
Craig Logan. Formed in 1986, they scored multiple top 10 hits between 1987 and 1989. In
Britain Bros also became the first modern era style boyband to have a multiple platinum selling album with
Push in 1988, which is still one of the most successful boyband albums in the
UK.
1990s
Although the term "boy band" did not exist until the 1990s, Boston group
New Edition is credited for starting the boy band trend in the 1980s.
Maurice Starr was influenced by New Edition and popularised it with his
protégé New Kids on the Block, the first commercially successful modern boy band who formed in 1984 and found international success in 1988. Starr's idea was to take the traditional template from the R&B genre (in this case his teenage band
New Edition) and apply it to a pop genre.
Some managers in Europe soon created their own acts after being inspired by
New Kids on the Block. First beginning with
Nigel Martin-Smith's
Take That in the
UK who formed in 1990 and followed by
Tom Watkins who had success with
Bros in the late eighties and formed
East 17 in 1991 who were marketed and pited against
Take That as rivals with a harsher attitude, style and sound.
Irish music manager
Louis Walsh had seen the impact of these two
British boy bands and put out an advert for an 'Irish Take That' creating
Boyzone in 1993.
[5] 911 formed in 1995 were another boy band who enjoyed success in Britain, however by the late 1990s all these bands had ran their course and split up. All these artists were very successful on both the singles and albums charts domestically and internationally however with the emergence of
britpop and the commercial co-option of
indie rock, many boy bands were ridiculed by the British music press as having no artistic credibility. The media attention was now placed on the
Battle of Britpop and the bands
Oasis and
Blur replaced the importance and rivalry of
Take That and
East 17 as the two new biggest bands in Britain.
In the late nineties in the UK, producer
Simon Cowell (noted in the U.S. for the American Idol/ X Factor franchise) is also known for having managed British boyband
Five formed in 1997 and Irish Republic boyband
Westlife who formed in 1998 and were created by Irishman
Louis Walsh as a replacement for
Boyzone[6] but were initially promoted by a former member of that band
Ronan Keating. They would go on to become the most successful boyband on the
UK Singles Charts. Cowell is now also currently having international success this decade with a new
British/
Irish boyband called
One Direction formed in 2010 on his show
The X Factor and signed to his label
Syco Music.
In North America boy bands were prominent in the 1990s like internationally after having started the modern concept with
New Kids on the Block. In the mid-1990s, most boy bands were African American and had R&B and gospel elements, such as the group
All 4 One formed in 1993 and
Boyz II Men formed in 1988 and who released their debut album in 1991.
Boyz II Men are also the most successful boy band act on the
US Hot 100 as well as the
Australian Singles Chart. Although they had success on the Billboard charts, they had been targeted to more of an adult audience and were not marketed for youth. It wasn't however until 1997 and the change to pop orientated groups like
Backstreet Boys,
98 Degrees,
'N Sync and
Hanson that boy bands exploded commercially and dominated the market in the
United States. This late nineties era marked the height of boy band popularity in North America which hasn't been seen since.
21st Century (2000s and 2010s)
The
Finnish rock band
HIM have been described by some, and even suggested by vocalist
Ville Valo[8] to be a boy band, despite their slightly darker imagery. This view became increasingly popular around the time of their international breakthrough album,
Razorblade Romance, stemming from the amount of lyrics revolving around
romance, as well as the band members' on-stage personas and tendencies to jokingly interact with one another during shows.
In 2001 a new all-male Japanese pop band and dance group boyband hailing from Japan called EXILE, debuted under Avex Group's label
Rhythm Zone with 14 members, putting them on par with
Super Junior as the largest boy bands in the world.
Some bands typically labeled as 'boy bands' have achieved larger success because their members create and play their own songs, trying to keep a level of musical performance up to their image.
Boston-based
power pop group
The Click Five is a recent example.
[9]
In North America the
Jonas Brothers had popularity helped from promotion on the
Disney Channel enabling them during 2008 to sell over 180,000 copies on albums in a week and hit number one on the American Billboard 200. However apart from the
Jonas Brothers boybands haven't seen the commercial boom experienced in the genre from the mid to late nineties in North America.
Moving into the 2010s boybands are still hugely popular especially in the
United Kingdom and the rest of
Europe due to the continued commercial presence and longevity of nineties boybands such as
Backstreet Boys,
Take That,
Boyzone and
Westlife. Some sections of the press have referred to these acts, particularly those who have reformed after a previous split, such as Take That and Boyzone, as 'man bands'. These older generation artists chart alongside
US5,
Lexington Bridge,
JLS,
The Wanted and
One Direction who are examples of new and currently successful boy bands from Europe.
Boy bands are also still very popular in Eastern Asia, notably so in
J-Pop and
K-pop, with successful groups such as South Korea's
Super Junior,
2PM,
TVXQ,
BIGBANG,
SHINee,
MBLAQ,
B2ST,
Infinite and
F.T. Island. Japan's
Arashi,
SMAP,
V6,
Tokio,
KinKi Kids,
KAT-TUN,
NEWS,
Kanjani 8, and
Hey! Say! JUMP top the
Oricon charts frequently. Taiwan also has notable boy bands like
Fahrenheit and
F4. Indonesia also has notable boy bands like
SM*SH, XO-IX, DragonBoyz, Treeji, S9B (Super Nine Boys), and Max5.
In America new boy bands include
Big Time Rush, and
Mindless Behavior who have experienced moderate success on the singles and albums charts including top ten placing debut albums on the American Billboard.
Key factors of the concept
Seen as important to a "boy band" group's commercial success is the group's
image, carefully controlled by managing all aspects of the group's dress, promotional materials (which are frequently supplied to
teen magazines), and
music videos. Typically, each member of the group will have some distinguishing feature and be portrayed as having a particular personality stereotype, such as "the baby," "the bad boy," or "the nice boy." While managing the portrayal of popular musicians is as old as
popular music, the particular pigeonholing of band members is a defining characteristic of boy and girl bands.
In most cases, their music is written, arranged and produced by a producer who works with the band at all times and controls the group's sound - if necessary, to the point of hiring
session singers to record guide vocals for each member of the group to sing individually if the members cannot harmonize well together. However, for clarity of each voice, recording each voice individually is most commonly the norm with most modern vocal groups. In recent years
auto-tune has become a popular tool for boybands who are unable to sing properly.
A typical boy band performance features elaborately
choreographed dancing, with the members taking turns singing and/or rapping. Boy bands generally didn't compose or produce their own material, unless the members lobbied hard enough for creative control (for example,
The Monkees, The Fukui Boys, and
'N Sync). However some bands were created around the talent of a songwriter within the group like
Gary Barlow of
Take That or
Tony Mortimer of
East 17.
Five were another group who wrote almost all their own songs. It isn't uncommon to find extra songs on the album written by one or more of the band members, however their producers rarely use these as singles.
Since the 21st Century however boybands have been expected to write or at least contribute in some part lyrically to songs. Apart from the groups mentioned above who all had at least one primary songwriter from their beginning, other groups soon caught up. From the late nineties band members saw the lucrative incentive of songwriting through track royalties and members in bands such as
Backstreet Boys who had previously used writers like
Max Martin or
Steve Mac during their early albums now began co writing. Modern groups of the last ten years such as
Busted,
McFly,
JLS and
Tokio Hotel etc. have all made a point from early interviews that they write their own songs and hold their own image as this is an important part of marketing. Some bands like
The Wanted have even spent time learning the craft of songwriting.
[10]
The key factor of a boy band is being trendy. This means that the band conforms to the most recent fashion and musical trends in the popular music scene. As of 2008, boy bands are more likely to be imitating
pop punk acts like
Blink 182, as well as the corresponding "
emo/
pop punk" fashion, as it is the current trend. A good example of this is the up and coming band
Allstar Weekend, who give off the appearance of being a punk band while still maintaining the elemnts of a Boy Band.
Music genres
Although most boy bands consist of
R&B or
pop influences, other
music genres, most notably
country music and
folk music, are also represented.
South 65 and
Marshall Dyllon, for example, were both considered country music boy bands, as was to a lesser extent
Rascal Flatts.
Il Divo, created by
Simon Cowell in 2004, are a band that perform
Operatic pop, and in several (mainly Italian) languages. Since then operatic/classical boy bands have become quite popular and common, especially in the UK. Since 2001 there has been some crossover with
power pop and
pop punk from bands that play live instruments. For example, as of 2008, boy bands are often influenced by pop punk,
post-grunge and power pop (a perennial genre). Just recently some boy bands decided to go back to their original doo-wop roots, most notably,
The Overtones.
Criticism
Since the 1990s, bands such as
Backstreet Boys,
*NSYNC, and
LFO have disliked the term "boy band" and have preferred to be known as a "Male Vocal Group". Boy bands have been accused by the music press of emphasizing the appearance and marketing of the group above the quality of music, deliberately trying to appeal to a
pre-teen audience and for conforming to trends instead of being original. Such criticisms can become extremely scathing. Boy bands are often seen as being short lived, though some acts such as
The Jackson 5,
New Kids On The Block, the
Backstreet Boys,
Boyzone,
Hanson,
Human Nature,
Westlife and
Take That[11] have sustained lasting careers, and in some cases, successful comebacks.
[12]